Cookie Puss Cake (Small)

Iconic ice-cream cake shaped like a face.

The Cookie Puss Cake (Small) has been part of the Carvel lineup for long enough that regulars order it by name without looking at the menu board. Iconic ice-cream cake shaped like a face.

Within the broader Desserts category at Carvel, this item competes for share against the chain's value-tier and premium options. The execution leans on consistent build specs across thousands of locations, which is why the experience of ordering one in Manhattan should be roughly identical to ordering one in Phoenix.

For pricing, Carvel typically positions this item in the mid-range of its menu — neither the cheapest entry-point item nor the most expensive specialty build. Calorie counts will vary slightly by location depending on portion-size discipline and any limited-time modifications running on the local promo calendar.

Pair it with the chain's signature side and a fountain drink for the standard combo experience, or order it à la carte if you're calorie-counting or testing the item before committing to a full meal. Mobile-app ordering occasionally unlocks customizations (extra sauce on the side, bun swaps, no salt) that aren't available at the in-store kiosk.

How it fits the menu

The Cookie Puss Cake (Small) sits in Carvel's desserts lineup, where it competes for share of stomach with the rest of the chain's 8 desserts options. At $24.99 and roughly 3,200 cal, it lands in the higher-calorie half of the menu — useful context whether you're calorie-budgeting for the day or just trying to maximize value.

Ordering tips

• Add it to a combo to bundle with fries (or a side) and a drink — usually 10–20% cheaper than ordering items separately.
• Customize through the mobile app for hidden modifier options that aren't on the in-store board.
• Watch for limited-time variants — chains rotate sauces, breading, and toppings on this category multiple times per year.
• Compare with the similar items below if you're choosing between brands on a road trip.